Compare virtue ethics consequentialist nonconsequentialist approaches to morality

However, one might fix on non-psychological goods as the relevant effect. In this view, the doctor is not required to promote life or decrease death or even decrease killing by other people.

Nonconsequentialist Theories: Do Your Duty

Although they have no real friends or lovers and actually accomplish nothing, people on the experience machine get just as much pleasure as if their beliefs were true.

The Act Itself, New York: Imagine that the doctor herself wounded the five people who need organs. Hence, there is no agreement on which theories count as consequentialist under this definition. Average real wages of US factory workers. Inherent in human life is the fact that time is limited.

Hence, hedonists who value propositional pleasure rather than sensational pleasure can deny that more pleasure is achieved by hooking oneself up to such an experience machine Feldman79—; see also Tannsjo and Feldman for more on hedonism.

Ovid wrote in his Heroides that Exitus acta probat "The result justifies the deed". Of course, doctors still should not cut up their patients in anything close to normal circumstances, but this example is so abnormal that we should not expect our normal moral rules to apply, and we should not trust our moral intuitions, which evolved to fit normal situations Sprigge When I decide to visit a friend instead of working for a charity, I can know that my act is not immoral even if I have not calculated that the visit will create enough overall good or that it will improve the world.

And there are also theories that attempt to hybridize different types of consequentialism with each other, or hybridize consequentialism with other types of ethical theories. One common move attacks opponents. By dropping one or more of those claims, descendants of utilitarianism can construct a wide variety of moral theories.

That seems implausible to many utilitarians. It also makes classic utilitarianism subject to attack from many angles. OEE arises in the context of the whole fundamental philosophy that is Objectivism: A direct consequentialist about virtues holds that the moral qualities of a character trait such as whether or not it is a moral virtue depend on the consequences of that trait Driver a, HurkaJamiesonBradley Individual moral agents do not know everything about their particular situations, and thus do not know all the possible consequences of their potential actions.

There are many different types of consequentialism that people can adopt. This self-esteem is acquired through the judgment—explicit or implicit—that one is capable of achieving happiness, and the knowledge that one fully intends to pursue that goal.

Motives and Rightness, Oxford: Deontological theories tend to focus on the motives of actions, and whether a given action was motivated by duty or something else.

Closely related is eudaimonic consequentialism, according to which a full, flourishing life, which may or may not be the same as enjoying a great deal of pleasure, is the ultimate aim. Individualist consequentialism may license actions which are good for the agent, but are deleterious to general welfare.

The medical profession depends on trust that this public rule would undermine. Rule consequentialists can respond that we should not claim special rights or permissions that we are not willing to grant to every other person, and that it is arrogant to think we are less prone to mistakes than other people are.

So, as a simple example, food is valuable to the person who is hungry. Consequentialism contrasted with other moral theories Consequentialism is often contrasted with deontology.

Williams, Moral Luck, Cambridge: The action must be performed not merely according to duty, but from duty. This form of utilitarianism holds that what matters is the aggregate happiness; the happiness of everyone and not the happiness of any particular person.

She selects her study partners according to their ambition and ability in the class, rather than their need for help. However, negative utilitarianism lays out a consequentialist theory that focuses solely on minimizing bad consequences. The applicability of the virtues, as with all of morality, depends on an individual making the choice to live, in some form, explicit or implicit.

If the only plausible options in moral theory lie on a certain list say, Kantianism, contractarianism, virtue theory, pluralistic intuitionism, and consequentialismthen consequentialists can argue for their own theory by criticizing the others.

Consequentialism is a type of teleological theory -- consequentialist theories suggest that the moral value, the moral rightness or wrongness of an act, is entirely a. May 18,  · Ethics and Action. 2 Basic Concepts in Moral Theory I. Introduction.

The Good. Virtue. Rights and Duties.

Moral Theory: A Non-Consequentialist Approach

Rights and Contracts. Rights and Consequentialism. Collision of Rights. provides a welcome alternative to current debates dominated by the consequentialist approach" Paperback.


"Compare Virtue Ethics Consequentialist Nonconsequentialist Approaches To Morality" Essays and Research Papers Compare Virtue Ethics Consequentialist Nonconsequentialist Approaches To Morality San Joaquin Valley College Different Approaches to Virtue By Martin P.

Aguayo Philosophy 1 C May 13, Virtue Ethics The Greeks though of virtue as excellence, but the biggest part of being virtuous is.

Ethics: A self-paced, online course from Propero

Compare act nonconsequentialist approaches to act utilitarianism and use them to resolve a moral problem; Compare the principles associated with consequentialist and nonconsequentialist approaches; Explain the moral framework of virtue ethics. Mar 26,  · An example of a consequentialism system of ethics would be utilitarianism, in which the most morally desirable situation is that in which people's happiness is maximized.

Virtue ethics - in which quality of character is the determiner of morality. Virtue Ethics. Consequentialist and non-consequentialist ethics are both centered around the idea of judging actions. But, there are other approaches to morality as well.

Compare virtue ethics consequentialist nonconsequentialist approaches to morality
Rated 0/5 based on 69 review
Ethics | Propero Courses